Payback

Marsoni

M251S

$24.95

Get it in 3 business days with 1 day shipping. Friday, May 29

PaybackFrom time to time, at one function or another, people will ask me when I began to hunt turkeys. When I tell them the truth, that I started in 1938, I often get the same look I would expect to get if I had answered, As soon as I got back from Appomattox. My deceased friend, Jim Andrews, whom I consider to be the best turkey hunter I ever saw, went through a 0 for the season one year in the last decade of his career. A 0 for the season did not happen to

Easy Shipping

Quick Dispatch:

Your Payback orders ship within 1-2 business days.

Delivery Options:

Standard: 3-7 business days
Fast: 2-3 business days
Express: 1-2 business days

Order Tracking:

You'll receive a tracking link by email once your Payback ships.

Need Help?
Questions about Payback, sizing, or delivery? We're just an email away.

Live Shipping Estimates:
Enter your location at checkout to see available shipping methods and costs for Payback in your area.

Get Shipping Estimates

Country Zip/Postal Code

Exchange/Return Notes

We offer a 30-day return/exchange service after receiving.
Final sale items are not eligible for returns or exchanges.
To process your return/exchange, please contact us at [email protected]
Please click here for more details>>> Return & Exchange Policy

I ordered these black Cole Haan penny loafers for casual wear with jeans, khakies, and even business casual with slacks and a jacket. They've always worked perfectly for these uses. The Cole Haan version is the most versatile and still meets my sophisticated look criteria. I wear a 9 1/2 M with almost all other shoes. I have found Cole Haan to run slightly wider and slightly shorter. This fit will work with thin and no socks and a little loose in width. . I'd likely order a 10 N next time. I tend to forget this but it runs consistent with me for Cole Haan. 5 stars for the shoe and service. My bad on the slightly off fit.

WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare

Reviewed in the United States on January 8, 2025

Verified Purchase

Hugh62

Whiting, US

★★★★★ 1

Poor quality control - maybe outlet store leftovers

Size: 11.5, Color: Burgundy Polished Full Grain

The two shoes were not the same size. They were both labeled 11 1/2 but one shoe was larger than the other and the fit was poor. I returned the first pair and ordered a replacement. This time the shoes were close to the same size but too loose and the left one has sewing issues. I've bought Johnston & Murphy for years because of the quality. These were to replace an existing pair of burgundy penny loafers that have finally worn out (even after several heal/sole replacements). That is the expected quality. I suspect Nashville Shoe Warehouse may be handling shoes that didn't measure up for the quality; more like an outlet mall than getting the J&M quality I've come to expect. Update: went to Johnston & Murphy site to buy "direct" from the manufacturer. There were several recent reviews where the shoes were long and didn't fit properly. Genesco - please step up the manufacture / crafting of these classic shoes to the level of quality they used to have.

WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare

Reviewed in the United States on July 21, 2025

Verified Purchase

Fabric Crazy

West Palm Beach, US

★★★★★ 5

Really nice shoes

Size: 9, Color: Black Polished Full Grain

My husband enjoys wearing these shoes. Very classy looking. They fit well. They arrived quickly. He liked them so much he ordered another pair in a different color which have worked out just as well.

WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare

Reviewed in the United States on February 3, 2026